Formerly u/CanadaPlus101 on Reddit.

  • 3 Posts
  • 1.06K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle




  • Sure… I’m asking whether you think there’s a big difference in people who would say “kill the fucker” and people who would actually stand behind advocating for the death penalty for him, irl, if needed.

    Well, we’re in a thread talking to a convicted pedophile, so I’ll refrain from judging morally. TBH I’ve found the more factual I am on the internet the better it goes.

    There’s a difference between saying it and genuinely believing it, yes. Although, most people aren’t actually going to decide if they’re serious until they have to, because ethical analysis of the criminal justice system isn’t a typical interest. It’s more of a spectrum of seriousness, really.

    and don’t the US serve convictions of like 3 consecutive life sentences so that it’d just a very surreal way of making sure they stay in jail?

    Yes, that is a thing. Legal fictions are funny.


  • Look, I’m sorry you got beat up, and I’m sorry you have all these health conditions. Since you actually seem to be listening, I’m also sorry for the downvotes.

    Unfortunately, shit is just going to be difficult for you now. It’s part of having a disability, and if you hurt someone else knowingly or unknowingly that gets even worse. I hope you can get your life back together one day.


  • I’m not arguing against anything you said.

    Oh, okay. Brought up out of the blue like that it seemed like you were suggesting I was in the picture. I actually tried to reach out as non-judgmentally as possible there, given the context.

    There was a text on it since like the 1600’s-1700’s, though it talked about why it’s not wise to hang burglars.

    Ah yes, I actually have seen that passage, although I can’t find it now. Punishing theft with death was actually particular to Germanic cultures IIRC. Even most ancient people thought that was stupidly harsh.

    Hmm. I wonder if this could be an argument against life sentences, too, since they’re similarly hard to add on to.

    Oh I’m sure you’re right, but are you saying that in a “people think ‘he should’ve died’ in a rhetorical way” or a “people actually think there should be the death penalty enacted for what he did”. I believe more the former and plenty the latter, but I wouldn’t say “most” for the latter.

    I deliberately didn’t specify, since it would have involved a digression, but I’d guess the same. People talk mad shit on the internet.


  • You’re arguing against a position I didn’t actually take. I pretty much just intended a reality check for OP there. People hate sex offenders and fear schizophrenics.

    Also, you’re kinda asserting you know what everyone else thinks.

    I’d put money on someone thinking that. More likely than not someone will even post it. Sure, it is a guess though.

    I mean, the first reply included “it’d be better to stop breathing”.